Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees
December 3, 2009
Minutes
In attendance: Emil Ronchi, Cathy Vaucher, John McEnaney, Dr John Sullivan, Bob Sousa, Matt Cronin, Nina Cullen Hamzeh. Ms Canavan arrived at 7:06. Dr. Alice de Koning arrived at 7:20
Location: Community Room at the Marblehead Community Charter Public School, 17 Lime St, Marblehead MA 01945
The Board of Trustee Chair, Mr. Emil Ronchi opened the meeting at 7:03P.M. He began by reciting the mission of MCCPS.
He went on to call for public comment. Noting there was no public comment, he continued.
Decision: Mr. McEnaney moved and Dr. Sullivan seconded a motion to approve the minutes of the November 5, 2009 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees.
Yeas: 7 Nays: 0 Abstain 0 Motion Passes
Mr. Ronchi recognized Dr. Argenziano for the Managing Director’s report, a copy of which is
attached. Dr. Argenziano also briefly added that he remains confident that the School will continue to see its payments from the State in line with expectations.
Mr. Ronchi recognized Ms Cullen-Hamzeh for a curriculum review from the Academic Director, a copy of which is
attached.
Mr. Ronchi notified the Board of Trustees that he has received a letter of resignation from Mr. Chris Fauci. A copy of the letter is
attached.
Mr. Ronchi recognized Ms Vaucher for the Governance report and to present a Trustee Candidate. Ms Vaucher informed Trustees that there were four Trustees who’s terms expired at the January 2010 meeting. She noted that all were eligible for reappointment and that each had affirmed to her a willingness to continue to serve.
Decision: Ms. Vaucher moved and Mr. Cronin seconded that the Board reappoint Mr. Emil Ronchi as a Class C trustee, to fill a three year term commencing at the close of the January 2010 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees, and expiring at the close of the January 2013 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees.
Yeas: 7 Nays: 0 Abstain 1 Mr. Ronchi recused himself. . Motion Passes
Decision: Ms Vaucher moved and Mr. Cronin seconded that the Board reappoint Mr. John McEnaney as a Class C trustee, to fill a three year term commencing at the close of the January 2010 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees, and expiring at the close of the January 2013 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees.
Yeas: 7 Nays: 0 Abstain 1 Mr. McEnaney recused himself. Motion Passes
Decision: Ms Vaucher moved and Ms Cullen Hamzeh seconded that the Board reappoint Dr. John Sullivan as a Class C trustee, to fill a three year term commencing at the close of the January 2010 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees, and expiring at the close of the January 2013 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees.
Yeas: 7 Nays: 0 Abstain 1 Dr Sullivan recused himself. Motion Passes
Decision: Mr. McEnaney moved and Mr. Ronchi seconded that the Board reappoint Dr. Alice de Koning as a Class C trustee, to fill a three year term commencing at the close of the January 2010 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees, and expiring at the close of the January 2013 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees.
Motion Tabled by the Chair until Dr. de Koning is present to acknowledge personally her willingness to serve.
Ms Vaucher introduced Mr. Bill Sullivan, currently a fifth grade teacher at the school, to the Board and provided a brief background of Mr. Sullivan. Mr. Sullivan addressed Trustees and entertained several questions from Trustees.
Decision: Ms. Vaucher moved and Ms. Canavan seconded a motion that the Board appoint Mr. Bill Sullivan as a Class B trustee, to fill a two year term commencing immediately upon approval by the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, and expiring at the close of the January 2012 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees.
Yeas: 8 Nays: 0 Abstain 1 Motion Passes
Decision: Ms Vaucher moved and Mr. McEnaney seconded a motion to invite the newly appointed Trustee Mr. Sullivan to all Board meetings and activities while his approval is pending with the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. Mr. Sullivan will be entitled to participate as provisional Trustee and will be able to participate in all activities and discussions, but will not be permitted to vote on any matter until he receives formal approval from the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, and will not be counted when determining a quorum.
Yeas: 9 Nays: 0 Abstain 0 Motion Passes
Dr de Koning arrived, and the Chair removed the previous motion from the table
Decision: Mr. McEnaney moved and Mr. Ronchi seconded that the Board reappoint Dr. Alice de Koning as a Class C trustee, to fill a three year term commencing at the close of the January 2010 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees, and expiring at the close of the January 2013 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees.
Yeas: 8 Nays: 0 Abstain 1 Dr. de Koning recused herself. Motion Passes
Ms Vaucher requested that the Chair recognize Ms Nancy Buczko of the Governance Committee to provide the Trustees a presentation from the Committee regarding the process for completing a Charter Amendment that would be necessary to change the enrollment and grades in accordance with our plan to expand. A copy of the presentation is
attached.
As a final Governance matter, Ms Vaucher noted that she has received a formal approval from the DESE for the Charter Amendment relating to enrollment policy that the Board approve in October. A copy of the approval letter is
attached.
Mr. Ronchi then recognized Ms Laura Jalbert, Chair of the Expansion Task Force. Ms Jalbert shared her report with Trustees, a copy of which is
attached. She informed Trustees asked Trustees for guidance around the elements of the MCCPS Expansion Dashboard, and there was some discussion among Trustees about what the critical information for the Board of Trustees to be aware of.
The Chair called a recess at: 8:08 PM
The Chair called the meeting back to order at 8:15 PM
The Chair then called on Dr. Sullivan for the Treasure’s Report, a copy of which is
attached. Dr Sullivan addressed key points in his report, and entertained several questions from Trustees about his report.
Mr. Ronchi called on Mr. Sousa to provide a Personnel Committee update. Mr. Sousa provided his report to Trustees in the form of the minutes of his most recent committee meeting, a copy of which is
attached. He added that he was seeking Trustee approval to begin the search for a full time managing director.
Decision: Mr. Sousa moved and Mr. McEnaney seconded that the Board authorized the Personnel Committee to begin the formal search process for a Managing Director and that the Board authorize up to $5,000 to support that search. The Chair of the Personnel Committee is responsible for allocating these funds.
Yeas: 8 Nays: 0 Abstain 1. Mr. Bill Sullivan did not vote. Motion Passes
The Chair recognized Mr. McEnaney who addressed the matter of the Board of Trustees goal to create a plan for developing non-tuition revenues.
Decision: Mr. McEnaney moved and Mr. Cronin seconded a motion that the Board of Trustees create a Task Force of the Board under Article VI, Section 1 of the By Laws to be called the Development Planning Task Force. The Development Planning Task Force shall prepare reports to be submitted and presented by its chair, or a representative designated by its chair, to the Board at each regularly scheduled Board meeting, or as may be required by the Board at special and/or emergency meetings beginning with the February 2010 Regular Meeting and continuing until the June 2010 Regular Meeting. The Development Task Force will be dissolved at the close of the June 2010 Regular Meeting unless the Board of Trustees reauthorizes the Task Force and provides specific guidance and direction for continued work.
The Task Force will include at least 5 and not more than 9 members, and shall be appointed by the Chair of the Board of Trustees so long as the Task Force includes at least one current faculty or staff member of the school and one parent of a current student at the school. The Chair of the Board of Trustees and the Managing Director will each be ex officio members of the Task Force.
The Task Force shall be responsible for:
a) Providing answers to the following inquires from the Board of Trustees:
· What are best practices among Charter Schools in regards to development?
-- How do Boards establish mid and long range development goals
-- What are some suggested relationships between the Board of Trustees, the School Administration and the MCCPS Educational Foundation regarding development activities
-- How is such a relationship reflected in other Charter Schools that have been successful in development.
· Gather and analyze data on non-PPE funding at other Charter Schools, both in and out of Massachusetts
· Identify what it is that MCCPS does that is marketable/saleable that would garner support – what aspects of the curriculum or programs could bring in significant donations.
· As we move forward in recruiting a full time managing director, how can we integrate our development efforts into that recruiting process.
b) Developing and presenting to the Board of Trustees a plan to annually generate non-tuition income of at least $275,000
c) Periodically evaluate its work as a Task Force and the objectives it has committed itself to and report on same to the Board;
d) Report to the Board at each regular meeting in a manner determined by the Board; and
e) Develop necessary policies and procedures, which shall be approved by the Board, to accomplish these duties.
Yeas: 9 Nays: 0 Abstain 0 Mr. Bill Sullivan did not vote. Motion Passes
The Chair asked Trustees if there were any new business. Ms Canavan reiterated that it is important that the community understand how the monies raised by the auction are being applied. Ms Cullen Hamzeh stated that she will work with the Finance Committee to ensure there is a consistent message.
Dr. Sullivan shared with the Board that Boston University will be donating 25 Dell PCs, and they will be available December 7, 2009.
Decision: Mr. McEnaney moved and Mr. Cronin seconded that the Board adjourn to executive session under exception seven of the Open Meeting Law, MGL Chapter 30A Section 11A1/2 for the express purpose of reviewing, approving, and determining the release status of the Executive Session Minutes for June 5, 2008, July 17, 2008, August 7, 2008, February 25, 2009, March 12, 2009, September 3, 2009, and November 5, 2009.
Ms Canavan, Yes; Ms Vaucher, Yes; Mr. Ronchi, Yes; Mr. McEnaney, Yes; Ms Cullen Hamzeh, Yes. Mr. Cronin, Yes. Mr. Sousa, Yes. Dr Sullivan, Yes. Dr de Koning, Yes Mr. Bill Sullivan did not vote Motion passes
The Chair noted that the Board of Trustees did not intend to return to open session at the conclusion of Executive Session. Additionally, he invited Dr. Argenziano to participate in Executive Session.
The meeting adjourned to Executive Session at 9:15
Respectfully Submitted
John T. McEnaney
Clerk
BACK
To: Board of Trustees
From: Dr. Albert F. Argenziano
Re: November Monthly Report
The month of November was one of the most active months in our school during the 2009-2010 school year. The highlights of the month are as follows:
November 10, 2009 - The Foundation held its monthly meeting and has moved forward with a letter campaign, which will go out this month. This is phase I of our efforts at supporting our budget with outside funding.
November 12, 2009 – The first Expansion Task Force meeting was held. A strong turnout of interested participants will lead to a monthly attempt at preparing the school for expansion.
November 7, 2009 – A successful auction was held at the Tedesco Country Club. It was an active, enjoyable evening. Many thanks to Eileen Perry and Pamela Haley for a job well done.
November 17,18,19, 2009 – A charter renewal visit took place on these dates. It is obvious since our last visit, that solid recovery has taken place. The enrollment and waiting list is at capacity. The curriculum, instruction and assessment model is solid and allows students to participate in an active learning environment. I am pleased that the school is safe, orderly and pleasant.
November 23, 2009 – The first annual Exhibition of our students work was held, and as always a standing room only crowd was in attendance.
In conclusion, we will be seeking a quality report on our renewal application. Since our last visit, we have dealt with our Leadership/Governance issues and feel that our former weakness is now our strength. The school has handled adversity, grown from it, and now awaits expansion and growth. My congratulations to the Board, Nina and the staff for a quality turnaraound.
P.S. Thanksgiving allows us the opportunity to say thank you to a professional competent Board, A dedicated committed staff, reflective intelligent students, and finally a concerned involved group of parents. To all,
Thank you.
BACK
To: MCCPS Board of Trustees
From: Nina Cullen-Hamzeh, Academic Director
12/3/09
Curricular Innovations:
MCCPS received a grant of $16,000 from the Gelfand Family Charitable Trust to fund our adoption of the KnowAtom Science Program for grades 4 & 5. This program is standards-driven, hands-on, and performance-based (just like MCCPS). We expect that it will enable us to provide an even higher level of learning experiences for our students.
The ELA/Math Initiative has resulted in improved student achievement in these subjects for most of the participants. The instructors, Ida Bazarova and Kay O’Dwyer, the Math/Science Department Chair, Rebecca Perry, and I have been meeting to review data related to student progress. Reports will be sent next week to the parents of participating students.
Fundraising:
Annual Auction - Parents have asked how the money raised from the auction will be used. I have explained that because the school is expected to raise $20,000 (that will be used as part of next year’s operating budget), that the administration is hesitant to spend this money until the obligation is met.
Grants - A grant was received from the Peter and Elizabeth C. Tower Foundation for $2072 for identified science equipment. The order has been placed, and the items should be in the classrooms soon.
Donation – An anonymous donation of $10,000 was received. Part of the money will be used (as requested by the donor) to support a dramatic production this school year. Some of the money will be used to address technology needs in the classrooms and computer lab.
Site Visit:
We should receive a preliminary report soon. The inspection team seemed more than satisfied with the documentation that we provided, the classroom visits, and the focus groups. Many contributed to the success of this site visit; thank you.
My apologies for the lack of a response to your last email.
Things are going very well and appreciate the kind words.
Re: my standing as a Board member, it seems best that I resign.
Thus, please accept this as my letter of resignation. Please pass my best wishes to the Board and the greater MCCPS community. I miss all of you much and thank you, Emil, in particular for all your great efforts and leadership.
Take care,
Chris
The Expansion Task Force has been assembled and has had one meeting on November 12, 2009. The goals and objectives were re-introduced and were sourced from meeting minutes of the Board of Trustees earlier motions to establish a continuing effort to pursue expansion possibilities by developing a plan, overseeing the work, identifying issues, quantifying savings and expenditures, tracking the schedule, making recommendations, evaluating its work and developing policies and procedures as necessary.
The committee revisited the outcome of the Blue Ribbon Task Force. It was clarified in the meeting that the intention was not to resurface issues that were already addressed but rather to move forward with the recommendation which is to "Expand the school, enter into a lease for the additional space for 17 Lime Stre; to add to sections of third grade, and to increase enrollment by 50 students, all with the intent to begin accepting students in the new grade and space for the 2011-2012 school year".
Key milestones were surfaced in the meeting and have contributed to a skeletal project plan upon which to establish details and to track progress and critical path dependencies. The draft architectural design was distributed for our review and consideration.
Outside of the meeting, I have prepared the proposed dashboard in order for the Board of Trustees to provide a measurable framework within which the task force can proceed with further analysis and definition of the important factors that would yield a successful end result.
Please forward this update and attachments to any other vested parties.
Regards,
Laura
The Charter School has entered the second quarter of the academic year ahead of plan. As of month end October, we have budgeted a surplus of $17 thousand. The actual surplus is $103 thousand. We are presently $86 thousand ahead of plan, but some of the budgeted expenses such as insurance payments (these are not spread out evenly over the year) and utilities have not yet been realized. The administration will need to watch the expenses closely as we move through the second quarter to ensure that we’re within budget.
We are still presently waiting to hear from the state as to our second quarterly payment. The finance committee is still committed to a raise for teachers that were here last year and continue to work at the school. The amount will be determined based on the check in December. In the meantime, Fin Com approved the allocation of $4,950 for payments to teachers that have been doing enrichments for Term 2. Fin Com also approved the Personnel Committee’s request for $5,000 to begin the search for a Managing Director.
Our administrators and faculty have also been working hard on grants. Over $18,000 grants have been provided to assist in (one grant for $16,000) sciences and also in special education ($2,000). Fin Com was also made aware that an anonymous donation of $10,000 has been made. I appreciate the hard work of our faculty and administration and the generosity of the donor.
The auction was also a great success. I have been told that it looks as though we will raise a net of $18,000. I want to thank all that donated and bid on the multitude of items as well as Eileen Perry and Pam Haley for all of their hard work.
Our annual audit is also in full gear. My wish is to have the audit to the board for our January meeting. Fin Com will also be soliciting new auditors for our next year’s budget. I hope to have several RFPs in place after the first of the year.
The loan restructuring is currently on hold until the Charter Renewal process is complete. I suspect that we’ll need to run at this issue, at the earliest, at the end of January.
As we end the year, I would also like to thank all those that have served on Fin Com this year: Francesco Rietti, Ira Keller, Peter Jalbert, John McEnaney, Jed O’Connor, Matt Cronin, Jeff Barry, Emil Ronchi, Dr. Argenziano, Nina Cullen-Hamzeh. I appreciate their time commitment to the Finance Committee and their dedication to the continued financial stability of the school.
The Chair opened the meeting at 7: 30 PM and first checked the previous month’s taskers from the November 3, 2009 meeting. The only tasker met was the submission of the previous month’s notes on proposed goals and measures for the Managing Director for 2010-2011 (See Attachment #1). The Chair also announced the resignation of Elizabeth Lutwak from the Committee.
Next the Committee discussed the process for advertising for a full time Managing Director for MCCPS. The discussion led to the Committee creating an ad to be placed in various employment search outlets (See Attachment #2). The Committee decided to have the Chair make a motion at the December 3, 2009 Board of Trustees meeting to begin the search process and for $5K to support the search.
The Committee then reviewed the rewritten draft of the 2009-10 Academic Director Goals and Measures. The Committee approved the draft and set the February 2, 2010 PC Meeting as the date for the Academic Director’s initial evaluation.
The rest of the meeting was used to continue discussion on creating an evaluation tool for the MCCPS Managing Director. The Chair suggested aligning the evaluation with the Academic Director’s as much as possible, because many of the previously identified goal headings (See Attachment #1) were general areas of interest in the AD document. The Committee discussed what qualities they thought were most important in the search, and in no particular order, they identified, embracing the MCCPS educational philosophy, ability to manage the budget/facility, ability to attract significant financial support through the creation of an effective development program. The discussion ended without the creation of a MD evaluation tool.
The Chair adjourned the meeting at 9:00PM. The next meeting will be held on Jan 7, 2010 at 7:30 PM.